• HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
Tamim Asset Management
  • HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Stock Insights

Ore You In or Out? Are BHP, RIO & FMG Worth Buying?

29/9/2021

1 Comment

 
This week we thought it may be pertinent to revisit our thesis around iron ore and in particular look at the big three players given the brutal nature of recent sell-offs of all three. Is it perhaps time to buy?
Iron ore stocks
​A Little Context
Sid Ruttala TAMIMAuthor: Sid Ruttala
​We’ve previously - late last year - made the bull case around the spot prices for iron ore (when the ore was trading at approx. 120 USD/T). Our reasoning here was summarised in a twofold explanation; 1) demand due to the likelihood of steel output staying consistent due to flooding in China; and 2) the increased fiscal expenditure globally, largely on infrastructure, which should see a disentanglement of the spot prices from Chinese demand. 

Recent price action, however, suggested otherwise with spot prices tumbling from a peak of 228 USD/T in May to now trading at 117 USD/T (at the time of writing). So, what's happened and why the decline?

The elephant in the room remains China. With China accounting for 70-75% of iron ore imports globally, any changes in demand have outsized impacts upon the global market. Beijing recently imposed caps on steel output as a result of and in the lead up to the 2022 Winter Olympics in the hopes of cutting emissions and controlling pollution. With domestic output having been allowed to expand beyond these caps through 1H21, we are likely to see continued declines until at least February of next year when the Winter Olympics are to be held. Combine this with some production coming back online in the form of Vale (Brazil), we have what may be considered a perfect storm. 

Let's now return to the second part of our argument; the disentanglement of spot prices from Chinese demand. Here we are seeing signs of reprieve. Take, for example, German import prices released by the Federal Statistics office, which saw the largest increases in import prices in close to forty years. Although this may be a result of supply bottlenecks, we are seeing increased demand for raw materials, with iron ore cost and end steel rising 95.8% in August, a period in which China’s imports of the product also hit peak. This indicates to us two things; first, Beijing may have coordinated a scenario where first half production was intentionally pushed above caps to taper off in the second half in the lead up to the Winter Olympics and, second, there is still surging global demand for the product on a longer term basis. This second aspect seems to be at play here. Major steel-producing provinces and regions are seeing inventory declines even during the offseason, with higher transaction volumes than would typically be the case in off-season markets this time of the year.

All this is to say that we are likely to see demand pick up with a vengeance coming out of the Winter Olympics and a rather messy situation in the lead up. This may be somewhat mitigated by shorter-term supply issues in the form of Vale, the most recent of which being 39 miners getting trapped in an underground mine at Totten. Nevertheless, we are still likely to see negative price action in 2H21 (or at the very least a consolidation pattern sideways) with 90 USD/T a great possibility.

Looking to the Longer-Term
Picture
​Looking to the longer term, however, our thesis broadly remains intact. That is, the continued fiscal impetus globally should see a rather massive tailwind for raw materials and steel. The oft touted Green New Deal Stateside is, in our view, likely to gain momentum in some form despite the recent gridlock in Congress. The more liberal wing of the democratic party may get its way with the stimulus bill despite facing an uphill challenge in the Senate. Why do we say so? 

The political imperative remains strong. Think for a moment about the voting patterns of the so-called Rust Belt and where US steel production is likely to take place should some semblance of the expansive infrastructure package be rolled out. These remain key and decisive swing states, Pennsylvania being one and Indiana, a key Republican stronghold and the largest producer of US steel, being another. All things equal, we are likely to see some incentive and political consensus especially when it comes to this aspect. What does this have to do with iron ore? Simple, we  are likely to see further demand increases from the US. 
​
Looking more globally, other key players continue to be the EU, where the marked shift to renewables is gaining traction for better or worse (most recently it has been in the news because of supply bottlenecks in traditional fossil fuels and an inability to cope with increased demand during winter). Nevertheless, we continue to see increasingly aggressive targets set by the Commission which formulated a directive to have 32% of energy consumption come from renewables by 2030. This came with a clause for upward revision in 2023 and carbon neutrality by 2050 (i.e. Renewable Energy Directive 2018/2001). Looking to emerging markets such as India where, notwithstanding recent cyclones that have buffeted steel producing states like Andhra Pradesh, we are seeing what could be termed as an infrastructure boom enabled by the government. Longer term, we see continued impetus on infrastructure spending, specifically transport infrastructure. We have seen the most recent union budget allocating close to $32bn US to the sector and new initiatives to wean the country off its reliance on diesel. Again, a focus on renewables also bodes well for the demand for iron ore. This remains a longer term play however, with ore imports still facing stiff competition and the steel industry being very much in its infancy. 

So, buy now or wait it out?

For the purposes of this article, let’s limit ourselves to the big three, BHP, RIO and FMG. All three have seen incredible declines from peak to trough. -32% for BHP, -43% for FMG, -28% for RIO. We make the case that, given the above rationale, the market may have overdone it. But, even assuming a 90 USD/T base case, we would still extrapolate a return to investors of 25% for BHP at this price (inclusive of dividend yield and assuming continued payout ratios of 90%). This is within the context of the spin-off in the petroleum business, continued upward pressure in the other aspect of steel production, coking coal, and BHP’s recent move into potash which we estimate should give an internal rate of return of 15% over the next 5 years (this is above management guidance (12-14%) given where we see agricultural markets going, but that is an article in and of itself). So, BHP? Perhaps a good buy. 
​
Let's get to Rio which continued to sell off, perhaps not as aggressively as the other two but consistent nevertheless. We also found this to be a little overdone and the market seems to have misplaced or overlooked the fact that this particular business has some of the largest uranium mining operations in the world. Given our thesis around that particular commodity (which we wrote about last year), we think RIO presents as a solid buy at the current price of $96.89 AUD. This implies a dividend yield of 10.9%, however, let us strip out the recent price action in iron ore and in fact go with the lower bear case of 90 USD/T, assuming current payout ratios hold we would still expect a yield of 8%. 
iron ore mining stocks
FMG, the pure play iron ore major, is another interesting story. Given the lower grades, it sits in the firing lines when it comes to any moves by Beijing to cut emissions. We do however contend that management has always had, and continues to have, good relations with the broader business community and has done a stellar job at managing its relations in that particular context. For those that have joined us in our line of thought around spot prices and the longer term potential, FMG offers a higher risk-reward play. At current prices, the implied dividend yield is a ridiculous 24%. Let us again use the lower for longer base case scenario of 90 USD/T. Assuming production stays consistent, we would still expect a grossed up dividend yield of approximately 11%.
​
So, basically, sell offs have been painful if you where an investor but all three present opportunities going forward in our view. BHP and RIO offer good value at current prices while FMG offers exceptional value if (and only if) you agree with our contention around the future of iron ore prices.


Disclaimer: BHP, FMG, RIO are currently not held in TAMIM portfolios.
1 Comment
frank maniscalco
30/9/2021 05:10:11 pm

have you taken into account future demand for iron ore from india?

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Stock Commentary

    At TAMIM we are committed to educating investors on how best to manage their retirement futures.

    Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter:

    * indicates required

    TAMIM Asset Management provides general information to help you understand our investment approach. Any financial information we provide is not advice, has not considered your personal circumstances and may not be suitable for you.

    Archives

    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015

    Categories

    All
    2016 Presidential Election
    5G
    AGM Season
    Apple (AAPL.NASDAQ)
    Asia Small Companies
    ASX
    ATL.AX
    Aus Equity All Cap Portfolio
    Aus Equity All Cap Value Portfolio
    Aus Equity Growth Portfolio
    Aus Equity Income Portfolio
    Aus Equity Small Cap Portfolio
    Australian Stocks
    Autonomous Vehicles
    Big Four Banks
    Brexit
    Electric Vehicles
    Emerging Markets
    Energy
    ENN.AX
    FAANG
    Financials
    Fintech
    Global Equity High Conviction Portfolio
    Global Mobility
    Gmg.ax
    Gold
    Growth Stocks
    Guy Carson
    Healthcare
    Income Investing
    Infrastructure
    International Stocks
    Investment Thematics
    IT Services
    Mergers & Acquisitions
    Mobility
    Pharma
    Property
    Rare Earths
    REITs
    Reporting Season
    Retail
    Robert Swift
    Ron Shamgar
    SLK.AX
    Small Cap Income Portfolio
    Small Caps
    Stock Report
    Takeovers
    Technology
    Telco Stocks
    Telstra (TLS.ASX)
    Tourism
    TPG
    Utilities
    Value Investing
    Video
    Wesfarmers (WES.ASX)

    RSS Feed

TAMIM | Equities | Property | Credit
​

TAMIM Fund
Australia All Cap
Australia Small Cap Income
Global Mobility
Global High Conviction
Credit

Listed Property
TAMIM Property
Company
About
Contact
Insights
Invest Online
Login
Other
Privacy Policy
Terms & 
Conditions
​Disclaimer
Contact
Level 4, 55 Grafton Street
Bondi Junction, Sydney NSW, 2022

1300 750 007

ima@tamim.com.au

DISCLAIMER

​The information provided on this website should not be considered financial or investment advice and is general information intended only for wholesale clients ( as defined in the Corporations Act). If you are not a wholesale client, you should exit the website. The content has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situations or needs. You should seek personal financial advice before making any financial or investment decisions. Where the website refers to a particular financial product, you should obtain a copy of the relevant product services guide or offer document for wholesale investors before making any decision in relation to the product. Investment returns are not guaranteed as all investments carry some risk. The value of an investment may rise or fall with the changes in the market. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. This statement relates to any claims made regarding past performance of any Tamim (or associated companies) products. Tamim does not guarantee the accuracy of any information in this website, including information provided by third parties. Information can change without notice and Tamim will endeavour to update this website as soon as practicable after changes. Tamim Funds Management Pty Limited and CTSP Funds Management Pty Ltd trading as Tamim Asset Management and its related entities do not accept responsibility for any inaccuracy or any actions taken in reliance upon this advice. All information provided on this website is correct at the time of writing and is subject to change due to changes in legislation. Please contact Tamim if you wish to confirm the currency of any information on the website.  

magellen, kosec, clime, wilson, wam, montgomery, platinum, commsec, caledonia, pengana, tamim

  • HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT