• HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT
Tamim Asset Management
  • HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Market Insights

What is the point of being ‘ESG compliant’?  The ‘Famous 5’ story may run and run.

2/5/2018

0 Comments

 
This week Robert Swift gets down and technical and takes a look ESG Compliance in the wake of the ongoing Hayne Royal Commission.
This is a brief article and somewhat ‘geeky’.  It is not directly about the Hayne Royal Commission although we will cite specific examples.  It is more about Environmental Social Governance (ESG) ‘analysis’ and whether it helps investors or whether it is marketing ‘spin’; or at least ‘spin’ as currently commonly used.  For those of you not living in Australia, the Royal Commission into the banks (and AMP, an insurance company) has revealed several embarrassing shortcomings and downright infraction of the regulations covering the provision of financial services.  The Famous 5 to which we refer in the title, and which are currently embarrassed on a daily basis, are the 4 major banks and the AMP.  It seems that shortcomings in process and incentives; ethics and the oversight of financial activities were not confined to everywhere but Australia after all.

We have a proposed solution to this and it is not more regulation, we already have plenty of that.  It seems that these organisations are:
  • Too large to manage internally – board diversity is great but how many board members have actually any idea how the provision of financial services operates and what is done by whom for whom to whom?
  • Too large to regulate – they have achieved regulatory capture and are an effective lobbying group 
  • Too large to prosecute – they can outspend the regulators on legal costs

Spot the common factor.

For the cynics (and oldies) amongst you we post a clip from the film Casablanca.  

We too are “shocked” (sic) to find that the inherent conflicts of interest in such large, complex, and vertically oriented organisations haven’t been supervised either by management; the board or the regulators.  What a surprise to find that human beings working in financial services in Australia responded in the same way to the same incentives of ‘carrot and stick’ as the human beings in the same industries in the USA and the UK!  

So often it is not the infraction that is the problem; people everywhere are wittingly or unwittingly committing a ‘crime’.  It is the (lack of) response to the infraction that is the problem.  This too appears common to the ‘Anglo Saxon’ world.  For more on why and how this culture has permeated listed companies then you should seek out work on executive compensation and share option incentives by Andrew Smithers.  We can email you a copy if you wish?

The problem with being “shocked” at revelations is that you are probably too late and the share price has fallen, or falling precipitously at a rate that makes selling the shares even more expensive to clients?  If you are “shocked” then your analysis has not picked up the risk and likelihood of this ESG shortfall ahead of the revelation?  You would be shocked if a company was found to be cheating on its accounts but you might admit that you didn’t dig deep enough?  Why is ESG any different if it is to be called analysis?  Consequently, what is the point of ESG “analysis” if it merely results in a coordinated shareholder vote of protest AFTER all the damage has been done?  It’s great to vote against the board after the event but hard to see how ESG compliance provides a competitive advantage if group think is prevalent?  It's great to be a signatory of the United Nations’ Principles of Responsible Investing (UNPRI) but not much practical use if you or they don’t speak up BEFORE the event?

Let’s move on to the point of the article.  It is not about the Australian banks nor the Australian regulators but really about ESG and whether it is effective as currently applied.

ESG assessment is the ‘analysis’ of companies (and we hope governments since they issue bonds to the capital markets and take taxes) in the dimensions of Environmental Social and Governance responsibility.  It is becoming increasingly important as a fund manager to have an approach to incorporate this aspect of capital stewardship.  We do apply ESG in our own way, albeit with a particular emphasis on related G elements and Accounting policies rather than that of religious zealots where evil is everywhere and in everything.

We highlight below the ESG scores for the ‘Famous 5’ and show in context to other Australian financial service entities we evaluate as part of our stock assessment model.  These have been drawn from Thomson Reuters database and are on a scale of 0 – 100 where 0 is pretty bad.  The Thomson Reuters model is a fairly rigorous assessment and evaluates over 70 dimensions to arrive at a final score.  There would appear to be no warning signals within all this information.  Other approaches may have been better however given that we are all “shocked” at what has recently been revealed we doubt it.
Picture
​Now for the geeky bit.  When we looked at the benefits of adding a new set of ESG factors to our existing model we discovered that there was positive correlation between the model and the ESG score.  Having a positive exposure to the VMQ rank also meant we had a better than reasonable chance of having positive exposure to good ESG scores.  In simple terms there was a positive non-trivial correlation which we show below.

The XY graph shows the trend line which is reasonably positive and the spread around the trend line appears wide but actually isn’t.  See us for some more geeky maths if you wish.  The R-squared between the VMQ and ESG scores currently is 0.27.
Picture
​In the following table of cross-sectional correlations, we show the average co-movement between the VMQ and the ESG scores.  Not only are the V (Valuation) and E (Environment) scores related but the ESG scores themselves appear to duplicate each other.  We have found that where V gets fooled is when G is poor and for this we always look to the accounting policies, auditing choice and board composition for further guidance and support.

Some would say this is merely what used to be called sensible research – whatever.  
Picture
Consequently you can be ESG compliant even without explicitly applying ESG rankings.  

If you still want to have separate ESG scores from other factors you consider when selecting stocks, then here is the next conundrum.  Having more factors to which you need positive exposure will increase portfolio turnover.  If the ESG factors decay, that is if there is a need to keep refreshing your portfolio to get exposure to the ESG factor, you will increase turnover and transaction costs of your portfolio.  If there is no decay of the ESG factor, how come it is an alpha factor to which you must have positive exposure?  If it doesn’t decay over time, it’s not alpha.

It is fine of course to want positive exposure to ESG considerations.  Just don’t call it an alpha factor.

Our conclusions in a presentation we gave at a recent conference on the practical challenges of incorporating ESG into the investment process were:
  • ESG is here to stay but there is plenty of evidence it doesn’t add to returns or isn’t alpha. 
  • Merely signing the UN PRI shouldn’t count.
  • It improves disclosure so we sort of like it.  We believe however that we’d rather be amongst the first to assess if something is wrong so we can exit the position.
  • Problems of coverage between regions and sizes of company.  Cultural differences about behaviours and labour laws and ‘engagement with officials’ mean that MY ESG is probably culturally different from YOUR ESG. Consequently ESG is a form of cultural imperialism in which western values may be foisted upon cultures with different needs and challenges? If there is no schooling after the age of 16 in parts of the world, then ‘child labour’ may be the only way for the family to earn money? School leaving age was as low as 14 in the UK in the early part of the 1900s; some economies are at similar stages of development.
  • Some well-loved companies have amongst the worst G scores – USA tech stocks have different voting rights and continually try to “pull a fast one” such as keeping the voting rights to stocks donated to charity!  Nice try.
  • There is no universal ESG ‘truth’!

We will have to see if there are remedial actions taken by the buyside after this Commission has finished.  There probably should be.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Markets & Commentary

    At TAMIM we are committed to educating investors on how best to manage their retirement futures.

    Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter:

    * indicates required

    TAMIM Asset Management provides general information to help you understand our investment approach. Any financial information we provide is not advice, has not considered your personal circumstances and may not be suitable for you.

    Archives

    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    July 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015

    Categories

    All
    Accounting
    AGM
    Amazon
    APRA
    Asia Small Cap
    Asset Allocation
    Aus Equity All Cap Value Portfolio
    Aus Equity Income Portfolio
    Aus Equity Small Cap Portfolio
    Australian Banks
    Australian Market Commentary
    Banking Royal Commission
    Big 4 Banks
    BNPL
    Brexit
    Budget
    China
    Corporate Governance
    Correlation
    Cryptocurrency
    Currency
    Darren Katz
    Dividend Yields
    Election
    Emerging Markets
    Energy
    GDP
    Global Equity High Conviction Portfolio
    Global Mobility
    Gold
    Guy-carson
    Housing
    Income Investing
    Inflation
    Infrastructure
    Insurance
    Interest Rates
    International Commentary
    Investment Thematics
    Investor Psychology
    Israel
    Japan
    Katz's Corner
    Kevin Smith
    Market Outlook
    Mergers-aquisitions
    Mobility
    Oil
    Passive-vs-active
    Peer-to-peer-lending
    Peertopeer-lending
    Portfolio Management
    Portfolio-management
    Private Debt
    Property
    Rando's Reflections
    RBA
    Recession
    REITs
    Reporting Season
    Retail
    Risk Management
    Robert Swift
    Ron Shamgar
    Small Cap Income Portfolio
    Small Caps
    Succesion Planning
    Telecoms
    The Pain Report
    Trade War
    Trump
    Value Investing
    Video
    ZIRP

    RSS Feed

TAMIM | Equities | Property | Credit
​

TAMIM Fund
Australia All Cap
Australia Small Cap Income
Global Mobility
Global High Conviction
Credit

Listed Property
TAMIM Property
Company
About
Contact
Insights
Invest Online
Login
Other
Privacy Policy
Terms & 
Conditions
​Disclaimer
Contact
Level 4, 55 Grafton Street
Bondi Junction, Sydney NSW, 2022

1300 750 007

ima@tamim.com.au

DISCLAIMER

​The information provided on this website should not be considered financial or investment advice and is general information intended only for wholesale clients ( as defined in the Corporations Act). If you are not a wholesale client, you should exit the website. The content has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situations or needs. You should seek personal financial advice before making any financial or investment decisions. Where the website refers to a particular financial product, you should obtain a copy of the relevant product services guide or offer document for wholesale investors before making any decision in relation to the product. Investment returns are not guaranteed as all investments carry some risk. The value of an investment may rise or fall with the changes in the market. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. This statement relates to any claims made regarding past performance of any Tamim (or associated companies) products. Tamim does not guarantee the accuracy of any information in this website, including information provided by third parties. Information can change without notice and Tamim will endeavour to update this website as soon as practicable after changes. Tamim Funds Management Pty Limited and CTSP Funds Management Pty Ltd trading as Tamim Asset Management and its related entities do not accept responsibility for any inaccuracy or any actions taken in reliance upon this advice. All information provided on this website is correct at the time of writing and is subject to change due to changes in legislation. Please contact Tamim if you wish to confirm the currency of any information on the website.  

magellen, kosec, clime, wilson, wam, montgomery, platinum, commsec, caledonia, pengana, tamim

  • HOME
  • INVESTMENTS
    • Equities >
      • Australia All Cap
      • Australia Small Cap Income
      • Global Mobility
      • Global High Conviction
    • Property >
      • Listed Property
      • TAMIM Property
    • Income >
      • Credit
  • INSIGHTS
    • Insights
    • Weekly Reading Lists
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT